PDA

View Full Version : Difference in results



Mixed
04-06-2017, 12:35 PM
On Family Tree I am 5% Eastern European. On Ancestry DNA I am 20%. That's quite a difference. On Gedmatch on some of the calcs I show quite a bit Slavic on some of them. Thoughts on why such a difference between the two testing services? My belief is that Austrian is more represented by Eastern Europe on Ancestry DNA.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Greek @ 18.150406
2 Norwegian @ 23.106342
3 Sicilian @ 23.924082
4 Turks_Istanbul @ 32.125443
5 Russian @ 32.840973
6 Turks_Aydin @ 35.675533
7 Turks_Balikesir @ 36.872173
8 Finnish @ 37.376751
9 Estonian @ 39.773254
10 Kurds_C @ 40.971451
11 Lithuanian @ 41.174194
12 Turks_Adana @ 41.264389
13 Kurds_N @ 41.276836
14 Turkmen_Afghan @ 41.367237
15 Uzbek @ 42.281845
16 Iraqi_Chaldeans @ 42.480759
17 Turks_Kayseri @ 42.541092
18 Iraqi_Arab_Baghdad @ 42.578663
19 Kurds_F @ 43.183636
20 Iraqi_Jew @ 43.764214

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Norwegian +50% Sicilian @ 3.993685


Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Russian +25% Stuttgart +25% Turks_Adana @ 3.561470


Using 4 populations approximation:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 Armenian + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 2.757118
2 Assyrian + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 2.810201
3 Armenian + Estonian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 2.820901
4 Armenian + Finnish + Russian + Stuttgart @ 2.923450
5 Assyrian + Estonian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 2.957180
6 Assyrian + Finnish + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.071897
7 Armenian + Russian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.125183
8 Assyrian + Russian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.237229
9 Iraqi_Chaldeans + Russian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.395234
10 Armenian + Finnish + Finnish + Stuttgart @ 3.396007
11 Norwegian + Russian + Sicilian + Sicilian @ 3.404643
12 BA_Sintashta + Greek + Iraqi_Arab_Baghdad + Sardinian @ 3.539096
13 Corded_Ware_LN + Greek + Iraqi_Arab_Baghdad + Sardinian @ 3.539096
14 Assyrian + Finnish + Finnish + Stuttgart @ 3.539406
15 Kurds_F + Russian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.557782
16 Russian + Russian + Stuttgart + Turks_Adana @ 3.561470
17 Armenian + Estonian + Finnish + Stuttgart @ 3.624088
18 BA_Sintashta + Greek + Kurds_F + Sardinian @ 3.635499
19 Corded_Ware_LN + Greek + Kurds_F + Sardinian @ 3.635499
20 Armenian + Finnish + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.654179

Admix Results (sorted):


# Population Percent
1 WHG 35.82
2 EEF 25.60
3 Caucasus 23.08
4 SW_Asian 7.11
5 Kalash 3.62
6 Gedrosian 2.79
7 Siberian 1.07


Finished reading population data. 86 populations found.
11 components mode.

--------------------------------

Least-squares method.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Bulgarian @ 7.018037
2 French @ 11.359632
3 Albanian @ 15.829486
4 Greek @ 18.290703
5 Norwegian @ 22.699316
6 Sicilian @ 23.760399
7 French_South @ 24.432062
8 Ashkenazi_Jew @ 24.727219
9 Turkish @ 33.615028
10 Russian @ 36.065994
11 Turkmen @ 37.131603
12 Tajik_Pomiri @ 38.003014
13 Turkmen_Afghan @ 38.264290
14 Uzbek @ 39.421089
15 Cypriot @ 39.834991
16 Finnish @ 40.123142
17 Tajik_Afghan @ 41.410900
18 Estonian @ 42.699493
19 Iranian @ 42.790264
20 Uzbek_Afghan @ 43.177582

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Norwegian +50% Sicilian @ 3.545611


Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Estonian +25% Iranian_Jew +25% Stuttgart @ 3.370728


Using 4 populations approximation:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 French + French_South + Iraqi_Jew + Russian @ 2.882629
2 Finnish + French + French_South + Iraqi_Jew @ 3.111251
3 Finnish + Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.116714
4 French_South + Iraqi_Jew + Norwegian + Norwegian @ 3.209654
5 Estonian + Finnish + Iranian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.278701
6 Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.301214
7 Assyrian + Finnish + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.337886
8 Finnish + French + French_South + Iranian_Jew @ 3.346179
9 Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.366549
10 Estonian + Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.370728
11 French + French_South + Iranian_Jew + Russian @ 3.410246
12 Finnish + Georgian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.436241
13 Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.471053
14 Assyrian + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.472262
15 Assyrian + Finnish + French + French_South @ 3.505134
16 Assyrian + French + French_South + Russian @ 3.509703
17 Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.543684
18 Norwegian + Norwegian + Sicilian + Sicilian @ 3.545611
19 Ashkenazi_Jew + Norwegian + Norwegian + Sicilian @ 3.554857
20 Estonian + Finnish + Georgian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.559901

Admix Results (sorted):


# Population Percent
1 WHG 35.82
2 EEF 25.60
3 Caucasus 23.08
4 SW_Asian 7.11
5 Kalash 3.62
6 Gedrosian 2.79
7 Siberian 1.07


Finished reading population data. 86 populations found.
11 components mode.

--------------------------------

Least-squares method.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Bulgarian @ 7.018037
2 French @ 11.359632
3 Albanian @ 15.829486
4 Greek @ 18.290703
5 Norwegian @ 22.699316
6 Sicilian @ 23.760399
7 French_South @ 24.432062
8 Ashkenazi_Jew @ 24.727219
9 Turkish @ 33.615028
10 Russian @ 36.065994
11 Turkmen @ 37.131603
12 Tajik_Pomiri @ 38.003014
13 Turkmen_Afghan @ 38.264290
14 Uzbek @ 39.421089
15 Cypriot @ 39.834991
16 Finnish @ 40.123142
17 Tajik_Afghan @ 41.410900
18 Estonian @ 42.699493
19 Iranian @ 42.790264
20 Uzbek_Afghan @ 43.177582

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Norwegian +50% Sicilian @ 3.545611


Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Estonian +25% Iranian_Jew +25% Stuttgart @ 3.370728


Using 4 populations approximation:
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1 French + French_South + Iraqi_Jew + Russian @ 2.882629
2 Finnish + French + French_South + Iraqi_Jew @ 3.111251
3 Finnish + Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.116714
4 French_South + Iraqi_Jew + Norwegian + Norwegian @ 3.209654
5 Estonian + Finnish + Iranian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.278701
6 Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.301214
7 Assyrian + Finnish + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.337886
8 Finnish + French + French_South + Iranian_Jew @ 3.346179
9 Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.366549
10 Estonian + Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.370728
11 French + French_South + Iranian_Jew + Russian @ 3.410246
12 Finnish + Georgian_Jew + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.436241
13 Iranian_Jew + Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Stuttgart @ 3.471053
14 Assyrian + Lithuanian + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.472262
15 Assyrian + Finnish + French + French_South @ 3.505134
16 Assyrian + French + French_South + Russian @ 3.509703
17 Estonian + Iranian_Jew + Russian + Stuttgart @ 3.543684
18 Norwegian + Norwegian + Sicilian + Sicilian @ 3.545611
19 Ashkenazi_Jew + Norwegian + Norwegian + Sicilian @ 3.554857
20 Estonian + Finnish + Georgian_Jew + Stuttgart @ 3.559901

MDLP K23b Oracle results:
MDLP K23b Oracle Rev 2014 Sep 16

Kit A026450

Admix Results (sorted):


# Population Percent
1 European_Hunters_Gatherers 31.84
2 Caucasian 26.96
3 European_Early_Farmers 22.74
4 Near_East 4.27
5 South_Central_Asian 4.22
6 Ancestral_Altaic 3.64
7 North_African 2.78
8 Amerindian 1.3
9 East_African 0.82
10 Melano_Polynesian 0.75
11 Archaic_African 0.3
12 Archaic_Human 0.15
13 South_Indian 0.15
14 Austronesian 0.07

Single Population Sharing:


# Population (source) Distance
1 Austrian ( ) 3.46
2 German-Volga ( ) 5.39
3 Hungarian ( ) 6.61
4 South_German ( ) 6.8
5 Slovenian ( ) 6.9
6 Italian_North ( ) 7
7 Hungarian_Budapest ( ) 7.93
8 German_East ( ) 8.77
9 North_German ( ) 8.87
10 Czech ( ) 9.36
11 German ( ) 9.47
12 Dutch ( ) 9.7
13 Serb_Serbia ( ) 10.36
14 Slovak ( ) 10.69
15 Belgian ( ) 11.36
16 Frisian ( ) 11.64
17 Dane ( ) 11.72
18 Kashub ( ) 12.06
19 Swede_Saami ( ) 12.18
20 Croat ( ) 12.74

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:


# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 57.9% Swede ( ) + 42.1% Ashkenazi_Jew ( ) @ 1.52
2 60.9% Dane ( ) + 39.1% Ashkenazi_Jew ( ) @ 1.59
3 64.4% Swede ( ) + 35.6% Romanian_Jew ( ) @ 1.62
4 65.2% Dane ( ) + 34.8% Ashkenazi ( ) @ 1.66
5 67.2% Dane ( ) + 32.8% Romanian_Jew ( ) @ 1.69
6 66.2% Swede ( ) + 33.8% Cretan ( ) @ 1.71
7 70.7% Dane ( ) + 29.3% Italian_South ( ) @ 1.72
8 62.5% Dane ( ) + 37.5% Sicilian_Siracusa ( ) @ 1.73
9 68% Swede ( ) + 32% Italian_South ( ) @ 1.75
10 62.3% Swede ( ) + 37.7% Ashkenazi ( ) @ 1.75
11 68.7% Dane ( ) + 31.3% Sicilian_Center ( ) @ 1.75
12 72.4% Swede ( ) + 27.6% Cypriot ( ) @ 1.8
13 65.3% Dane ( ) + 34.7% Sicilian_East ( ) @ 1.8
14 72.8% Dane ( ) + 27.2% Greek_Islands ( ) @ 1.84
15 57.9% Italian_North ( ) + 42.1% German ( ) @ 1.86
16 62.8% Dane ( ) + 37.2% Greek_Peloponnesos ( ) @ 1.88
17 67.6% North_German ( ) + 32.4% Ashkenazi_Jew ( ) @ 1.88
18 70.3% Swede ( ) + 29.7% Greek_Islands ( ) @ 1.88
19 70.1% Austrian ( ) + 29.9% Italian_North ( ) @ 1.92
20 62.4% Swede ( ) + 37.6% Sicilian_East ( ) @ 2