PDA

View Full Version : Ethnically Polish results in Living DNA



Tomenable
04-05-2018, 08:22 PM
My results. 2% Pashtun-related DNA seems to be the "missing link" between Balto-Slavs and Indo-Iranians:

https://i.imgur.com/2zL1NR9.png

https://i.imgur.com/vXp6TLi.png

Mike_G
04-06-2018, 02:05 AM
My results. 2% Pashtun-related DNA seems to be the "missing link" between Balto-Slavs and Indo-Iranians:

https://i.imgur.com/2zL1NR9.png

https://i.imgur.com/vXp6TLi.png

Looks very accurate to me :\

kingjohn
04-06-2018, 07:15 AM
My results. 2% Pashtun-related DNA seems to be the "missing link" between Balto-Slavs and Indo-Iranians:

https://i.imgur.com/2zL1NR9.png

https://i.imgur.com/vXp6TLi.png

nice B)
how many months it took them to give you results ?

p.s
i think an eastern pole will have different results from you
as you score significant germanic admixture 13.4%

Angriff
04-08-2018, 01:55 AM
nice B)
how many months it took them to give you results ?

p.s
i think an eastern pole will have different results from you
as you score significant germanic admixture 13.4%

I'd assume most of what it puts into Great Britain for him is probably germanic as well.

Rethel
04-08-2018, 11:09 AM
My results. 2% Pashtun

To teraz jesteś Talibem? Z Klewek? :heh:

http://old.niepoprawni.pl/files/images/klewki_0.jpg

Lion Heart
04-08-2018, 03:32 PM
Still biased towards the UK I think. How accurate was Ydna and mt-dna with it? can u share some eurogenes with the living dna kit?

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 04:23 PM
To teraz jesteś Talibem? Z Klewek? :heh:

http://old.niepoprawni.pl/files/images/klewki_0.jpg

a pashtun in a pole is aryan genes this the real deal :thumb:

Fungene
04-08-2018, 05:14 PM
My results. 2% Pashtun-related DNA seems to be the "missing link" between Balto-Slavs and Indo-Iranians:

https://i.imgur.com/2zL1NR9.png

https://i.imgur.com/vXp6TLi.png
No unassigned even in Cautious Mode? That's pretty good.
Looks like Living DNA might be tailoring what their regions include to each customer. My report in Cautious Mode has everything Pannonia lumped into a general "Aegean-related ancestry" category, which includes the East Balkans, Greece and Southern Italy, but excludes the West Balkans.
Anybody else seeing this?

sktibo
04-08-2018, 05:18 PM
It doesn't matter who you are, at Living DNA, you get a Cornwall percentage!

Fungene
04-08-2018, 05:26 PM
It doesn't matter who you are, at Living DNA, you get a Cornwall percentage!

So true. Even I get 1.2% Cornwall in Cautious mode Sub Regions (for those who haven't tested with LDNA: only Great Britain and Ireland get subregions in Cautious mode).
Haven't been to Cornwall in ages. Maybe it's time for a trip.

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 06:46 PM
So true. Even I get 1.2% Cornwall in Cautious mode Sub Regions (for those who haven't tested with LDNA: only Great Britain and Ireland get subregions in Cautious mode).
Haven't been to Cornwall in ages. Maybe it's time for a trip.

living dna in the biggest test of there life
with my sample becuse i only have 0.5% celto germanic dna in eurogenes k36
ah and i score 0.5% french ......
i am so corious what they will give me ........
if they will give me british region even more than 1% than this test have a lot more work to do .......

surbakhunWeesste
04-08-2018, 07:40 PM
To teraz jesteś Talibem? Z Klewek? :heh:

http://old.niepoprawni.pl/files/images/klewki_0.jpg

Where is the Pashtun? All eastern brown men with beard = talibans? If you must promote pashtuns = taliban, get the pics talibans at least? smh

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 07:43 PM
Where is the Pashtun? All eastern brown men with beard = talibans? If you must promote pashtuns = taliban, get the pics talibans at least? smh

he knows deep in his hourt who is the real aryan and this is you my dear :)
and other south central asians linguisticly , genetically :)

sktibo
04-08-2018, 07:53 PM
living dna in the biggest test of there life
with my sample becuse i only have 0.5% celto germanic dna in eurogenes k36
ah and i score 0.5% french ......
i am so corious what they will give me ........
if they will give me british region even more than 1% than this test have a lot more work to do .......

I think your results are going to be fairly off, and I think they do have a lot of work to do. Thankfully, they are doing it. Their Irish project is ~60% complete, their German one is ~40% complete, and they have started working on their Scotland project. Hopefully this year we will be able to transfer our data from other companies to Living DNA, and through that we'll not only be able to get more Anthrogenica members in there to compare with, we will also be able to see the difference between the data from older chips and the newer imputation chip that they use. My own results from Living DNA show that they are far from being able to separate an individual's actual ethnic mix from what I call the "average" of their ancestry. Yeah, it gets some of it right, for sure, but it looks like it gets an equal amount, if not more wrong. I remain hopeful that this company will end up improving to a great degree in this year.

I'm quite interested in Tomenable's result as I'm trying to find some sort of DNA hint as to the origins of my Eastern European ancestry. Living DNA gave me 3.6% Europe East broken into 1.3 Baltic, 1.2 Finland/West Russia, and 1.1 West Balkans. Since 23andme recently assigned me a slight (one dot) relationship with people from Poland, I'm looking into that possibility - it looks like Living DNA also assigned these three regions to Tomenable, so that lines up, but I'm lacking anything from the largest percentage he received.

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 07:58 PM
I think your results are going to be fairly off, and I think they do have a lot of work to do. Thankfully, they are doing it. Their Irish project is ~60% complete, their German one is ~40% complete, and they have started working on their Scotland project. Hopefully this year we will be able to transfer our data from other companies to Living DNA, and through that we'll not only be able to get more Anthrogenica members in there to compare with, we will also be able to see the difference between the data from older chips and the newer imputation chip that they use. My own results from Living DNA show that they are far from being able to separate an individual's actual ethnic mix from what I call the "average" of their ancestry. Yeah, it gets some of it right, for sure, but it looks like it gets an equal amount, if not more wrong. I remain hopeful that this company will end up improving to a great degree in this year.

you might be correct
but i want to get it, it is more than month in testing mode :\
but it is always better to test with a company than to transfer raw data from other company
so i dont regret i bought it .... just a person need patience of iron :)

sktibo
04-08-2018, 08:00 PM
you might be correct
but i want to get it, it is more than month in testing mode :\
but it is always better to test with a company than to transfer raw data from other company
so i dont regret i bought it .... just a person need patience of iron :)

Because they are bound to update their results, I don't think you will regret testing with them. Even if the results are not good, it should be entertaining or interesting. I, personally, am very interested in how your Jewish heritage will appear on their test - and I actually think it is very interesting - perhaps more interesting than other tests - that they don't have specifically Jewish categories.

td120
04-08-2018, 08:18 PM
No unassigned even in Cautious Mode? That's pretty good.
Looks like Living DNA might be tailoring what their regions include to each customer. My report in Cautious Mode has everything Pannonia lumped into a general "Aegean-related ancestry" category, which includes the East Balkans, Greece and Southern Italy, but excludes the West Balkans.
Anybody else seeing this?

Strange...In my Cautious Mode Pannonia is grouped with "Northeast Europe-Related ancestry" .

https://imgur.com/56RqtZT

Did not get British Isles . My Germanic seems on the high too...

https://anthrogenica.com/showthread.php?9647-Living-DNA-Results&p=295065&viewfull=1#post295065

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 08:35 PM
Because they are bound to update their results, I don't think you will regret testing with them. Even if the results are not good, it should be entertaining or interesting. I, personally, am very interested in how your Jewish heritage will appear on their test - and I actually think it is very interesting - perhaps more interesting than other tests - that they don't have specifically Jewish categories.

south italy + levant and some 5% east europe { must be some gentile blood from my grandmother}
could be also iberian stuff as i am 1/4 sefhardi and i score 14% iberian in k36 {not shy number}

Fungene
04-08-2018, 08:53 PM
Strange...In my Cautious Mode Pannonia is grouped with "Northeast Europe-Related ancestry" .


https://anthrogenica.com/showthread.php?9647-Living-DNA-Results&p=295065&viewfull=1#post295065


It does appear they give the same regions different names; they also change the names of the regions at different levels of analysis.
Here's my Cautious mode map:
22556

At least you don't get Cornwall!
That being said, I find combining LivingDNA Complete mode with 23andme at the 60%-70% confidence level gives good results. I am looking forward to LivingDNA's version of 23andme's DNA Relatives.

kingjohn
04-08-2018, 09:22 PM
It does appear they give the same regions different names; they also change the names of the regions at different levels of analysis.
Here's my Cautious mode map:
22556

At least you don't get Cornwall!
That being said, I find combining LivingDNA Complete mode with 23andme at the 60%-70% confidence level gives good results. I am looking forward to LivingDNA's version of 23andme's DNA Relatives.

fungene care to share your eurogenes k36 results from gedmatch will be much appreciated
i want to see if it is inline with your living dna results ?
kind regards
adam

Fungene
04-08-2018, 10:50 PM
Sure thing.
Here is the K36 based on LivingDNA:
22557

kingjohn
04-09-2018, 02:45 PM
Sure thing.
Here is the K36 based on LivingDNA:
22557

thanks :)
is your 23and me v5 values are more or less the same ?
becuase they use differnt chip or the overlapp of markers between lliving dna snp set to other companies is very low
kind regards
Adam

Fungene
04-09-2018, 02:58 PM
thanks :)
is your 23and me v5 values are more or less the same ?
becuase they use differnt chip or the overlapp of markers between lliving dna snp set to other companies is very low
kind regards
Adam

Yes, by 99.7%

Alain
04-09-2018, 03:58 PM
Where is the Pashtun? All eastern brown men with beard = talibans? If you must promote pashtuns = taliban, get the pics talibans at least? smh Bin Laden not a Pashtun, he is from the Arabian pensula. I found in Pashtun people with green/bluegray eyes (but rare) sometimes blond hair

Alain
04-09-2018, 04:05 PM
there are also Poles with black hair and beard one can not generalize everything, at least the right Aryans from Central Asia come to Pashtun, Nuristani, Pamiri ... and is very rare in Europe and has nothing to do with Germany

kingjohn
04-09-2018, 05:04 PM
there are also Poles with black hair and beard one can not generalize everything, at least the right Aryans from Central Asia come to Pashtun, Nuristani, Pamiri ... and is very rare in Europe and has nothing to do with Germany

so true many people paid there lives for this lie ..... { not only jews }

Rethel
04-10-2018, 06:30 PM
It is interesting, how some people can make a big
problem becasue they saw a one arabian guy on a
photo, not even understanding what it is all about...

Mis
04-10-2018, 06:46 PM
Yes it's true

kingjohn
04-10-2018, 07:06 PM
It is interesting, how some people can make a big
problem becasue they saw a one arabian guy on a
photo, not even understanding what it is all about...

you should at least post a real pashtoon rather than usama bin laden which is arabian ....

surbakhunWeesste
04-11-2018, 12:00 AM
Bin Laden not a Pashtun, he is from the Arabian pensula. I found in Pashtun people with green/bluegray eyes (but rare) sometimes blond hair

Hazel eyes aren't rare but blue/gray/green eyes aren't common, blond/red hair rare and most lose it as they grow old.

@ User Rethel, it is a big deal when one's ethnicity gets meticulously scorned irl based off actions of few, I guess it's a granted privilege to joke and be fine, never known what prejudice can infer eh.
That's not JUST an Arabian guy ffs.

surbakhunWeesste
04-11-2018, 12:02 AM
you should at least post a real pashtoon rather than usama bin laden which is arabian ....

Ah and perhaps he should post Mullah Omar eh, coz the joke is about taliban and Pashtun ;) it seems just fine I suppose.