Paternal Granmother's Brother came back as being E-M96

[jeanL]

So basically I just tested the sole surviving brother of my paternal grandmother, he is 94 years old and has dementia. Fortunately, the DNA was captured on the first attempt and now I have his 23andme results. Anyhow, as the title says, his paternal haplogroup came back as E-M96; given that his version of 23andme is V5, I wonder if this is an artifact of the new chip, or if he is a legit E-M96(xE-P147, xE-M75). Any advice? Per the scientific details page of 23andme's y-dna haplogroup it makes it seem like they do test for E-P147 and E-M75, yet I do not know if the tree is version specific (i.e., V5) or if it is generic.

32791

[Ruderico]

Have you tried https://ytree.morleydna.com/ yet?

[jeanL]

Have you tried https://ytree.morleydna.com/ yet?

I'll try it as soon as I get home and get my hands on his raw data. Thanks for the tip.

[C J Wyatt III]

You might want to get him a FTDNA Family Finder test or Y-37 if you can spend a bit more, currently on sale for the next day or two.

That would get a sample on file at FTDNA if you ever needed to do more detailed Y-DNA testing.

The FTDNA sampling is usually easier for a person in his state, because it uses cheek swabs rather than spitting.

[jeanL]

Have you tried https://ytree.morleydna.com/ yet?

Here are the results:

A100-,A150-,A210-,A260-,A286-,A3-,A421-,A9-,BY126-,BY151-,BY159-,BY184-,BY352+,BY451-,CLFY12861-,CLFY2971-,CLFY3449+,CLFY7251-,CLFY7476-,CTS1019-,CTS10349+,CTS10349-,CTS10729-,CTS1078-,CTS10814-,CTS11342-,CTS11468+,CTS11468-,CTS11577-,CTS11962-,CTS12-,CTS1230-,CTS1243-,CTS1257-,CTS1264-,CTS1382-,CTS155-,CTS16-,CTS1858-,CTS1966-,CTS2022-,CTS2100-,CTS2335-,CTS241-,CTS2457-,CTS2457.1-,CTS2457.2-,CTS2514-,CTS2734-,CTS2873-,CTS300-,CTS3226-,CTS3529+,CTS3745-,CTS3818-,CTS4075+,CTS4075+,CTS4075-,CTS4231-,CTS4415-,CTS4437+,CTS4922+,CTS5488-,CTS5551-,CTS5854-,CTS5914-,CTS5981-,CTS6048+,CTS623+,CTS623-,CTS6280-,CTS6554-,CTS7556-,CTS7734-,CTS7976-,CTS8627-,CTS8995-,CTS9018+,CTS9018-,DF13-,DF17-,DF63-,F100-,F1100-,F1120-,F1150-,F1193-,F1204-,F1265-,F1295-,F1319-,F1329-,F134-,F1365+,F3393-,F36-,F4320-,F446-,F450-,F632-,F719-,F879-,F91-,F996-,FA1341-,FB1464+,FB941+,FE2801-,FGC1109-,FGC11144-,FGC11203-,FGC11555-,FGC1160-,FGC11660-,FGC12405-,FGC12993-,FGC13494-,FGC1566-,FGC1698-,FGC17449-,FGC1774-,FGC18564-,FGC188+,FGC1897+,FGC19462+,FGC20064-,FGC20560-,FGC22501-,FGC22538-,FGC22963-,FGC31715-,FGC3213-,FGC37+,FGC3754-,FGC3763-,FGC3872-,FGC4077-,FGC42+,FGC4620-,FGC4888-,FGC49+,FGC5496-,FGC5628-,FGC63-,FGC69-,FGC7535-,FGC7892-,FGC8512-,FGC8628-,FGC9807-,FL299-,H:14313115(C|T)-,IMS-JST003305-,K193-,K:14004634(A|G)-,K:14251166(G|A)-,K:14363549(G|T)-,K:15591446(C|T)-,K:15591446(C|T)-,K:15591446(C|T)-,K:17444848(G|A)-,K:21473656(G|A)-,K:2745262(C|A)-,K:6621096(T|C)-,K:7046288(A|G)-,K:7192612(T|A)-,K:8311520(A|T)-,K:8418520(T|C)-,L1029-,L1085-,L1096-,L1101+,L1248-,L1263-,L1308-,L1388-,L1392-,L14-,L1425+,L162-,L199-,L208-,L21-,L212-,L254-,L258-,L281-,L295+,L320-,L321-,L35-,L443-,L455-,L484-,L517-,L527-,L529-,L529.1-,L529.2-,L56-,L573-,L644-,L645-,L655-,L675-,L699-,L720-,L744-,L784-,L80-,L816-,L857-,L93-,M1109-,M12-,M1203-,M12111-,M12132-,M124-,M124-,M124-,M124-,M1264-,M1313-,M1470-,M1522-,M1546-,M16-,M16-,M1667-,M181-,M200-,M200-,M227-,M227-,M227-,M2308-,M240-,M267-,M2718-,M2745-,M2783-,M2834-,M2856-,M3372-,M3636-,M3658-,M3690-,M387-,M387-,M4266-,M428-,M428-,M428-,M428-,M461-,M4747-,M4793-,M4827-,M4859-,M51-,M529-,M533-,M5420+,M5475+,M5524-,M5549-,M5571+,M64-,M64.1-,M64.2-,M68-,M68-,M682-,M6886-,MEH2-,MEH2-,P102+,P102+,P102+,P102+,P116-,P116-,P126-,P127-,P173+,P196-,P221-,P229-,P257-,P260-,P260-,P280-,P292-,P298-,P304-,P321-,P324-,P324-,P34_3-,P58-,P6-,P6-,P72-,P72-,P72-,P72-,PAGES00002-,PAGES00008-,PAGES00021-,PAGES00032-,PAGES00042-,PAGES00044-,PAGES00053-,PAGES00071-,PF1395-,PF1558+,PF1697+,PF1792-,PF1837-,PF2017-,PF2137-,PF2284-,PF2622-,PF2668-,PF27-,PF2950-,PF3149-,PF3233-,PF3237-,PF3362-,PF3526-,PF3558+,PF3664-,PF3706-,PF3720+,PF3858-,PF3862-,PF3892-,PF4646-,PF4698-,PF4782-,PF4811-,PF4832-,PF4845-,PF4888-,PF4988-,PF5087-,PF5116-,PF5118-,PF5371-,PF5670-,PF5862-,PF5893-,PF6019-,PF6068-,PF6093+,PF6093-,PF6127+,PF6127-,PF6234-,PF6249-,PF6271-,PF6419-,PF6452-,PF6466-,PF6478-,PF6484-,PF6492-,PF6520-,PF6543-,PF6584-,PF7258-,PF7406-,PF7589-,PF:13963821(T|C)+,PF:14136291(A|G)+,PF:14432928(A |G)+,PF:16751825(A|G)+,PF:17013730(A|G)+,PF:181171 93(T|C)+,PF:21843090(G|C)+,Page65.1-,S1157-,S1159-,S120-,S130-,S145-,S15526-,S16196-,S1743-,S18765-,S1938-,S206-,S22865-,S23612-,S244+,S246-,S257-,S263-,S265-,S271-,S27175-,S27194+,S27216-,S27370+,S274-,S27445+,S27447-,S27531+,S27568+,S27598-,S27631-,S27643+,S27683-,S27696+,S27699-,S27769+,S280-,S299-,S324-,S335-,S380-,S384-,S388-,S439-,S4554-,S47+,S483-,S497-,S521-,S522-,S5488-,S5520-,S5556-,S6365-,S7402-,S7474+,S7655-,S8235+,S9403-,SK1106-,SK1151-,SK1254-,SK1662-,SRY10831+,SRY10831.1+,SRY10831.2-,U181-,U6-,V100-,V169-,V23-,V231-,V28-,V42-,V57-,V68+,V82-,Y11277-,Y1150-,Y2016-,Y2225+,Y2250-,Y2905-,Y2990-,Y3302-,Y3455-,Y3517-,Y4010-,Y4272-,Y4332-,Y4752-,Y4925-,Y5568-,Y5585-,Y57-,Y6885-,Y6996-,Y7060-,Y7152-,Y7214-,Y8394-,Y8712-,Y8945-,YFS026499-,YP414-,YSC0000047-,YSC0000054-,YSC0000131-,YSC0000167-,YSC0000191-,YSC0000194-,YSC0000227+,YSC0000234-,YSC0001299-,Z11-,Z1147-,Z12222-,Z12480+,Z12485-,Z12522-,Z12530-,Z12535-,Z12640-,Z1296-,Z1298-,Z13450-,Z13911-,Z13966-,Z141-,Z1426-,Z14266-,Z14405-,Z146-,Z14686-,Z147-,Z14979-,Z150-,Z16329-,Z16403-,Z16521-,Z16684-,Z167-,Z16713-,Z16775-,Z17028-,Z17627-,Z17685-,Z17699-,Z17815-,Z17819-,Z18081-,Z1846-,Z1853-,Z1865-,Z18886-,Z19-,Z1919-,Z1936-,Z19639-,Z2058-,Z2103-,Z2106-,Z2115-,Z2118-,Z2124-,Z23193-,Z23269-,Z2329-,Z23769-,Z2381-,Z23858-,Z24048-,Z246-,Z2541-,Z25907-,Z2638-,Z2649+,Z272-,Z2845-,Z2953-,Z30-,Z304-,Z30583-,Z306-,Z329-,Z331-,Z36-,Z381-,Z382-,Z4367-,Z4842-,Z49-,Z5-,Z55-,Z58+,Z5860-,Z5863-,Z5870-,Z5873-,Z5887-,Z59-,Z5985-,Z5986-,Z5993-,Z6000-,Z6013-,Z6014-,Z6017-,Z61-,Z639-,Z6552-,Z6642-,Z739-,Z741-,Z7941-,Z7944-,Z808-,Z810-,Z8127-,Z8143+,Z827-,Z843-,Z8440-,Z859-,Z971-,ZP23-,ZS20-,ZS2025+

It says most likely: E1b1b1a-E-PF2182 (E-L539, E-CTS10323).

It also says:


This suggested classification does not account for the following positive SNPs:

BY352
CLFY3449
CTS3529T
CTS4075
CTS4437
CTS4922
CTS6048
FB1464
FB941
FGC188
FGC1897
FGC19462
FGC37
FGC42
FGC49
L1425
L295
M5420
M5475
M5571
P102
PF1558
PF1697
PF3558
PF3720
PF:13963821(T|C)
PF:14136291(A|G)
PF:14432928(A|G)
PF:16751825(A|G)
PF:17013730(A|G)
PF:18117193(T|C)
PF:21843090(G|C)
S244
S27194
S27370
S27445
S27531
S27568
S27643
S27696
S27769
S47
S7474
S8235
Y2225
YSC0000227
Z12480
Z2649
Z58
Z8143
ZS2025

[Farroukh]

Is it possible to transfer his data to FTDNA and to order Y-DNA test?
His preliminary result (L539+, M78- ???) is non-trivial and interesting

[C J Wyatt III]

Is it possible to transfer his data to FTDNA and to order Y-DNA test?
His preliminary result (L539+, M78- ???) is non-trivial and interesting

The Y-DNA test needs an actual sample. The data from another test is not applicable.

The different DNA testing vendors do not generally transfer DNA samples. You need to actually test at FTDNA to get your sample saved there for any other testing which you might want from them in the future. A sample might be used for mtDNA, autosomal DNA or Y DNA testing or a combination thereof if the sample has enough to go around, but each test needs to use real DNA.

[jeanL]

Is it possible to transfer his data to FTDNA and to order Y-DNA test?
His preliminary result (L539+, M78- ???) is non-trivial and interesting

Unfortunately the person in question is in another country and I do not have a way to test him using FTDNA anytime soon.