PDA

View Full Version : Deciphering GED.com Results in comparison to FTDNA Results



Cboatman
02-07-2014, 12:34 AM
I upload my FTDNA raw data to GED.com and the results are not the same/similar, so I'm a little confused as to what it all means. GED.com is telling me I have Mediterranean ancestry.

According to FTDNA I got this:

83% Africa (West African) - Yoruba .11% of error
17% Europe - Finnish, French, Orcadian, Romanian, Russian .11% of error


On GED.com I got this:

MDLP World-22 Oracle results:

Kit F269462

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 Sub-Saharian 77.69
2 Atlantic_Mediterranean_Neolithic 5.26
3 North-East-European 4.78
4 Near_East 3.67
5 Pygmy 3.01
6 Indian 1.27
7 Samoedic 1.01
8 Paleo-Siberian 0.94
9 Austronesian 0.51
10 South-African 0.48
11 West-Asian 0.46
12 Mesoamerican 0.35
13 South-America_Amerind 0.33
14 Indo-Iranian 0.22

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 Lemba (derived) 14.03
2 Bantu (derived) 17.05
3 Mandenka (derived) 24.95
4 Sub-Saharian (ancestral) 25.06
5 Yoruba (derived) 25.06
6 Biaka_Pygmies (derived) 33.67
7 Ethiopian (derived) 55.1
8 Jew-Ethiopia (derived) 58.76
9 Jew_Ethiopia (derived) 59.83
10 Lumbee (derived) 61.86
11 Moroccan (derived) 65.9
12 Mozabite (derived) 71.97
13 Yemen (derived) 72.96
14 Australian (derived) 74.92
15 Egyptian (derived) 77.79
16 Puerto-Rican (derived) 78.67
17 Jordanian (derived) 83.07
18 Ste7 (derived) 83.97
19 Miwok (derived) 84.95
20 Mexican (derived) 85.96

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% British (derived) @ 3.77
2 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% CEU (derived) @ 3.78
3 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Orcadian (derived) @ 3.78
4 82% Lemba (derived) + 18% Lumbee (derived) @ 3.79
5 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% Welsh (derived) @ 3.88
6 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% French (derived) @ 3.89
7 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% German-South (derived) @ 3.96
8 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Norwegian_V (derived) @ 3.99
9 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% CEU_V (derived) @ 4.09
10 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% German_V (derived) @ 4.15
11 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% Swedish (derived) @ 4.17
12 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Austrian (derived) @ 4.18
13 87.3% Lemba (derived) + 12.7% Swiss (derived) @ 4.18
14 88.1% Lemba (derived) + 11.9% Basque (derived) @ 4.2
15 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% German-North (derived) @ 4.27
16 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% Provancestralal (derived) @ 4.28
17 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% Swedish_V (derived) @ 4.32
18 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Spaniard (derived) @ 4.35
19 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% German (derived) @ 4.37
20 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Hungarian (derived) @ 4.39


What do you all think?

vettor
02-07-2014, 04:53 PM
I upload my FTDNA raw data to GED.com and the results are not the same/similar, so I'm a little confused as to what it all means. GED.com is telling me I have Mediterranean ancestry.

According to FTDNA I got this:

83% Africa (West African) - Yoruba .11% of error
17% Europe - Finnish, French, Orcadian, Romanian, Russian .11% of error


On GED.com I got this:

MDLP World-22 Oracle results:

Kit F269462

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 Sub-Saharian 77.69
2 Atlantic_Mediterranean_Neolithic 5.26
3 North-East-European 4.78
4 Near_East 3.67
5 Pygmy 3.01
6 Indian 1.27
7 Samoedic 1.01
8 Paleo-Siberian 0.94
9 Austronesian 0.51
10 South-African 0.48
11 West-Asian 0.46
12 Mesoamerican 0.35
13 South-America_Amerind 0.33
14 Indo-Iranian 0.22

Single Population Sharing:

# Population (source) Distance
1 Lemba (derived) 14.03
2 Bantu (derived) 17.05
3 Mandenka (derived) 24.95
4 Sub-Saharian (ancestral) 25.06
5 Yoruba (derived) 25.06
6 Biaka_Pygmies (derived) 33.67
7 Ethiopian (derived) 55.1
8 Jew-Ethiopia (derived) 58.76
9 Jew_Ethiopia (derived) 59.83
10 Lumbee (derived) 61.86
11 Moroccan (derived) 65.9
12 Mozabite (derived) 71.97
13 Yemen (derived) 72.96
14 Australian (derived) 74.92
15 Egyptian (derived) 77.79
16 Puerto-Rican (derived) 78.67
17 Jordanian (derived) 83.07
18 Ste7 (derived) 83.97
19 Miwok (derived) 84.95
20 Mexican (derived) 85.96

Mixed Mode Population Sharing:

# Primary Population (source) Secondary Population (source) Distance
1 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% British (derived) @ 3.77
2 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% CEU (derived) @ 3.78
3 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Orcadian (derived) @ 3.78
4 82% Lemba (derived) + 18% Lumbee (derived) @ 3.79
5 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% Welsh (derived) @ 3.88
6 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% French (derived) @ 3.89
7 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% German-South (derived) @ 3.96
8 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Norwegian_V (derived) @ 3.99
9 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% CEU_V (derived) @ 4.09
10 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% German_V (derived) @ 4.15
11 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% Swedish (derived) @ 4.17
12 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Austrian (derived) @ 4.18
13 87.3% Lemba (derived) + 12.7% Swiss (derived) @ 4.18
14 88.1% Lemba (derived) + 11.9% Basque (derived) @ 4.2
15 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% German-North (derived) @ 4.27
16 87.5% Lemba (derived) + 12.5% Provancestralal (derived) @ 4.28
17 87.8% Lemba (derived) + 12.2% Swedish_V (derived) @ 4.32
18 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Spaniard (derived) @ 4.35
19 87.7% Lemba (derived) + 12.3% German (derived) @ 4.37
20 87.6% Lemba (derived) + 12.4% Hungarian (derived) @ 4.39


What do you all think?

the gedmatch mixed mode population sharing for 2, 3 or 4 races are all equal , you can use any of the 20 listed that best suits your needs. you could be numbers 11 or 20 in your mixed mode population.

I only look at the oracle choices ( 1 or 2) as my best fit