Kashubian Polish results

[Little bit]

Click the resolution button to get to speculative:
https://www.23andme.com/published/ancestry/composition/a9502d0993002933/f9f74efe78b5ae86/

FTDNA and Ancestry:

http://i953.photobucket.com/albums/ae20/LB234/th_Screenshot2014-10-23at54656AM_zps65e7f6fa.png (http://s953.photobucket.com/user/LB234/media/Screenshot2014-10-23at54656AM_zps65e7f6fa.png.html)

Eurogenes EUtest V2 K15 4-Ancestors Oracle:

# Population Percent
1 Baltic 28.84
2 North_Sea 27.76
3 Atlantic 16.45
4 Eastern_Euro 15.65
5 West_Med 5.43
6 West_Asian 3.28

Least-squares method.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 Estonian @ 7.451365
2 South_Polish @ 7.660712
3 Ukrainian @ 7.778255
4 Ukrainian_Lviv @ 7.800802
5 Polish @ 7.891741
6 Finnish @ 10.210291
7 Belorussian @ 11.107287
8 Southwest_Finnish @ 11.271881
9 Russian_Smolensk @ 11.397657
10 Estonian_Polish @ 12.159723
11 Southwest_Russian @ 12.228398
12 Lithuanian @ 12.567585
13 Ukrainian_Belgorod @ 12.739174
14 Hungarian @ 13.239334
15 East_German @ 13.714237
16 East_Finnish @ 13.776028
17 La_Brana-1 @ 14.066832
18 Croatian @ 14.178986
19 Kargopol_Russian @ 16.136461
20 Moldavian @ 16.433775

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Lithuanian +50% Swedish @ 4.986827


Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Lithuanian +25% Ukrainian_Lviv +25% West_Norwegian @ 3.254365


Using 4 populations approximation:
1 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Ukrainian_Lviv + West_Norwegian @ 3.254365
2 Estonian + Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.358232
3 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Ukrainian + West_Norwegian @ 3.533077
4 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.623232
5 Estonian + Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian @ 3.628350
6 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Norwegian + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.652711
7 Estonian + Lithuanian + Norwegian + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.702654
8 Estonian + Lithuanian + Ukrainian_Lviv + West_Norwegian @ 3.726162
9 Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian_Lviv + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.748364
10 Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.763085
11 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + South_Polish + West_Norwegian @ 3.794914
12 Estonian + Lithuanian + South_Polish + Swedish @ 3.819522
13 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian @ 3.846848
14 Lithuanian + Swedish + Ukrainian + Ukrainian @ 3.875186
15 Lithuanian + Polish + Swedish + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.879349
16 Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Norwegian + Ukrainian @ 3.900410
17 Lithuanian + South_Polish + Swedish + Ukrainian_Lviv @ 3.915010
18 Hungarian + Lithuanian + Lithuanian + Swedish @ 3.966986
19 Belorussian + Lithuanian + Ukrainian_Lviv + West_Norwegian @ 3.968132
20 Estonian + Lithuanian + Norwegian + Ukrainian @ 3.976274

T2b according to 23andme, T2b7a1 + 16519C per the mtdna analysis tool. I'm curious about the Asian at 23andme but not found at FTDNA or Ancestry and the 8% Southern Europe at FTDNA but not shown at 23andme or Ancestry. Any other Eastern Europeans take all 3 tests and know which is offering the most reliable results? Thanks!

[Salkin]

Interesting. Would you mind posting MDLP K23b results also?

[Little bit]

Sure, no problem. Looks like she got Kashub 2nd. When I researched her great grandparents, some renounced the King of Prussia and others the Emperor of Germany on their Declaration of Intent's to become a U.S. citizen. I know it was the same guy but it must have meant something to them to choose one over the other. Here is her results:

MDLP K23b Oracle Rev 2014 Sep 16

Admix Results (sorted):

# Population Percent
1 European_Hunters_Gatherers 49.63
2 Caucasian 25.44
3 European_Early_Farmers 15.76
4 South_Central_Asian 3.88
5 Ancestral_Altaic 2.68


Finished reading population data. 620 populations found.
23 components mode.

--------------------------------

Least-squares method.

Using 1 population approximation:
1 German @ 3.257933
2 Kashub @ 4.847866
3 Slovak @ 5.152075
4 Sorb @ 6.783828
5 Ukrainian_West @ 6.905407
6 Czech @ 6.958454
7 Finn_West @ 7.448657
8 Slovenian @ 7.957340
9 Hungarian @ 8.171726
10 Russian_Meshtchyora @ 8.867240
11 Russian_North @ 8.927165
12 Belarusian_West @ 9.075987
13 Hungarian_Budapest @ 9.099261
14 Russian-West @ 9.163200
15 Russian-North-West @ 9.250031
16 Swede_Saami @ 9.325566
17 Ukrainian_Center @ 9.485973
18 Belarusian-East @ 9.501294
19 Russian_South @ 9.955241
20 Ukrainian_East @ 9.987016

Using 2 populations approximation:
1 50% Belarusian_Russian +50% Frisian @ 1.724051


Using 3 populations approximation:
1 50% Frisian +25% Lithuanian +25% Mixed_East_Slav @ 1.272274


Using 4 populations approximation:
1 Belarusian_Russian + Frisian + Frisian + Lithuanian @ 1.271901
2 Frisian + Frisian + Lithuanian + Mixed_East_Slav @ 1.272274
3 Belarusian_Russian + Frisian + Irish + Lithuanian @ 1.332535
4 Frisian + Irish + Lithuanian + Mixed_East_Slav @ 1.337131
5 Belarusian + Frisian + Frisian + Lithuanian @ 1.419873
6 Irish + Kashub + Latvian + Slovenian @ 1.478825
7 Dutch + Frisian + Lithuanian + Pole @ 1.491836
8 Belarusian + Frisian + Latvian + South_German @ 1.503501
9 Frisian + Frisian + Latvian + Mixed_East_Slav @ 1.517028
10 Frisian + Kashub + Latvian + Slovenian @ 1.518387
11 Belarusian_Russian + Frisian + Frisian + Latvian @ 1.520819
12 Don_cossack + Frisian + Latvian + North_German @ 1.530198
13 Belarusian_Russian + Frisian + Latvian + South_German @ 1.530261
14 Frisian + Hungarian + Kashub + Latvian @ 1.531493
15 Belarusian + Dutch + Frisian + Lithuanian @ 1.532976
16 Frisian + Latvian + Mixed_East_Slav + South_German @ 1.536442
17 Belarusian + Frisian + Irish + Lithuanian @ 1.537116
18 Belarusian + Belarusian_South + Frisian + North_German @ 1.544128
19 Hungarian + Irish + Kashub + Latvian @ 1.552842
20 Belarusian + Belarusian_Russian + Frisian + Norwegian_East @ 1.554732

Done.

[Salkin]

Thanks. K23b continues to impress, even if it put Kashub 2nd rather than 1st.

[Little bit]

Yes, I agree that the MDLP K23b is more specific and informative.