PDA

View Full Version : Ftdna vs 23andme



paulo412
11-06-2015, 01:49 PM
Hi all, I am newbie,

This is my test :
FTDNA
54 % European
- Western and Central Europe : 29%
- Southern Europe : 25%
29 % African
- West African : 25 %
- East Central Africa : 3 %
- South-Central Africa : 1%
12 % Natve American
4 % East Asian
2 % Middle Eastern

dodecad world 9 admixture :
Population
Amerindian 16.13%
East_Asian 0.34%
African 27.52%
Atlantic_Baltic 34.36%
Australasian 0.60%
Siberian -
Caucasus_Gedrosia 5.46%
Southern 15.55%
South_Asian -

DNA LAND ???
Southwestern European (29.53%) Ashkenazi/Levantine (11.09%) North/central European (10.95%)
West African (17.01%), East African (10.02%), Native American (15.21%), Other (6.19%)

Some people said me to get 23andme test, what I can learn more. I am obsessed by my origin. I was adopted at my 10, I don't know my parents. And I know that can't make profile of my parents origin. I am surpised that my biggest European inherit is Western and Central Europe, I know Sao Paulo is very mixed European and someones came from Western Europe and Central... Italian.... And dna land it's beta version and make different test...

Thanks

paulo412
11-06-2015, 06:01 PM
what is better?

vettor
11-06-2015, 06:12 PM
Hi all, I am newbie,

This is my test :
FTDNA
54 % European
- Western and Central Europe : 29%
- Southern Europe : 25%
29 % African
- West African : 25 %
- East Central Africa : 3 %
- South-Central Africa : 1%
12 % Natve American
4 % East Asian
2 % Middle Eastern

dodecad world 9 admixture :
Population
Amerindian 16.13%
East_Asian 0.34%
African 27.52%
Atlantic_Baltic 34.36%
Australasian 0.60%
Siberian -
Caucasus_Gedrosia 5.46%
Southern 15.55%
South_Asian -

DNA LAND ???
Southwestern European (29.53%) Ashkenazi/Levantine (11.09%) North/central European (10.95%)
West African (17.01%), East African (10.02%), Native American (15.21%), Other (6.19%)

Some people said me to get 23andme test, what I can learn more. I am obsessed by my origin. I was adopted at my 10, I don't know my parents. And I know that can't make profile of my parents origin. I am surpised that my biggest European inherit is Western and Central Europe, I know Sao Paulo is very mixed European and someones came from Western Europe and Central... Italian.... And dna land it's beta version and make different test...

Thanks


there is a database that shows the people who left north-east italy from 1880 to 1910 for Sao Paulo and Rio del Sol in Brazil ............2 million migrated.

do you have a surname I can use?

Tolan
11-06-2015, 06:31 PM
......

paulo412
11-06-2015, 06:47 PM
My family name is Pereira and Rodrigues, that is only information that I had.

ArmandoR1b
11-06-2015, 07:33 PM
Paulo,

Based on the results of many Latin Americans, Iberians, and northern Europeans your Dodecad World9 admixture results are the most accurate. FamilyTreeDNA has a problem with correctly assigning Native American (Amerindian) and DNA LAND assigns Ashkenazi/Levantine to people that do not get Ashkenazi anywhere else. Your Atlantic_Baltic 34.36% and Southern 15.55% in World9 and Southwestern European (29.53%) but 0% South European at DNA.Land points to you having a lot of Iberian ancestry which is probably mainly Portuguese.