23 and me results

[Raza94]

Hey guys I started a thread a while back with my cousins results hes also on this forum known as Moahk. Anyways I decided to go and get my own DNA test done through 23&me and was wondering if anyone here could help decipher it or maybe lead me in the right direction.

on 23&me it shows 99.1% South Asian

Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 7.25.52 PM.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 7.25.38 PM.png

This is what I got through Harrapa but I have heard that it is not the best calculator. If anyone has any suggestions about what calculator to use that would be great.

A little background is that we claim "Syed" ancestry. Paternal side is from Jhang, Punjab in Pakistan and Mothers side is from Sialkot, Punjab in Pakistan.

Y haplogroup-R-M417
mt- m5a2a1

Thank you.

[Censored]

What is the other .9%?

[kush]

Hey guys I started a thread a while back with my cousins results hes also on this forum known as Moahk. Anyways I decided to go and get my own DNA test done through 23&me and was wondering if anyone here could help decipher it or maybe lead me in the right direction.

on 23&me it shows 99.1% South Asian

Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 7.25.52 PM.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 7.25.38 PM.png

This is what I got through Harrapa but I have heard that it is not the best calculator. If anyone has any suggestions about what calculator to use that would be great.

A little background is that we claim "Syed" ancestry. Paternal side is from Jhang, Punjab in Pakistan and Mothers side is from Sialkot, Punjab in Pakistan.

Y haplogroup-R-M417
mt- m5a2a1

Thank you.

Can you post your mixed population results as well from harappa? Harappa is a good calc imo not sure why many don't like it. Its like a base for south asians. You can try Eurogenes K13, ANE K7, MDLP K16, MDLP k23b, Dodecad k12b, Puntdnal K13 global, and Eurasia K9 ASI. These are some good calcs imo.

You might have some west asian type ancestry based on your E african, elevated SW asian. Also, your euro is quite low for that region so that's interesting as well.

[Censored]

Agree with Kush you need to show your mixed population results also. Your NE Euro is quite low while Caucasian and E. African is high and SW Asian is elevated. I predict there is some kind of mixture but from that information alone it's almost impossible to tell what.

[MonkeyDLuffy]

Damn that's low Euro. I said it last time as well, you've west asian input. Judging from super low steppe, it could be somewhere south Iran.

[Raza94]

Hey guys so the other 0.9 % is 0.4% European,0.4% East Asian/Native American and 0.1 unassigned. This is my Harrapa mixed population results

Harrapa Mixed.png

And this is Eurogenes K13

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.24.34 AM.png

k13 single.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.25.23 AM.png

Yea I see a lot of West Asian in the Eurogenes K13 calculator. How recent would do you guys think this would be?

[kush]

Hey guys so the other 0.9 % is 0.4% European,0.4% East Asian/Native American and 0.1 unassigned. This is my Harrapa mixed population results

Harrapa Mixed.png

And this is Eurogenes K13

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.24.34 AM.png

k13 single.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.25.23 AM.png

Yea I see a lot of West Asian in the Eurogenes K13 calculator. How recent would do you guys think this would be?

yeah you definitely have some west asian ancestry. You are getting iranian in the population splits and you are getting that with bhatias, kalash, and sindhis present in the oracles. not sure how recent this is though. Also can you post the mixed mode population from regular 'oracle' rather than the 'oracle-4'? Post it both for harappa and eurogenes k13. This way it will show what your primary population is and in what direction you deviate from it through the secondary population.

[Censored]

Hey guys so the other 0.9 % is 0.4% European,0.4% East Asian/Native American and 0.1 unassigned. This is my Harrapa mixed population results

Harrapa Mixed.png

And this is Eurogenes K13

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.24.34 AM.png

k13 single.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 10.25.23 AM.png

Yea I see a lot of West Asian in the Eurogenes K13 calculator. How recent would do you guys think this would be?

Your west Asian isn’t that high for your region. however east Med and Red Sea are so that says something. I just don’t get why nothing is showing up on 23andme.

[Raza94]

yeah you definitely have some west asian ancestry. You are getting iranian in the population splits and you are getting that with bhatias, kalash, and sindhis present in the oracles. not sure how recent this is though. Also can you post the mixed mode population from regular 'oracle' rather than the 'oracle-4'? Post it both for harappa and eurogenes k13. This way it will show what your primary population is and in what direction you deviate from it through the secondary population.

Here they are for both EuroGenes K13 and Harrapa

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 7.48.46 PM.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 7.47.30 PM.png


I also went and tried the K23b calculator and these are the results I got:
Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 7.51.27 PM.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 7.52.37 PM.png

Screen Shot 2018-03-25 at 7.53.00 PM.png

Not sure if this matters but I am using the genesis beta on GEDMatch. On the site it said if you're using the 23&me V5 chip its better to use genesis.

[Raza94]

Your west Asian isn’t that high for your region. however east Med and Red Sea are so that says something. I just don’t get why nothing is showing up on 23andme.

Think it may have anything to do with the V5 chip? I have seen people complaining about it