Exactly, and this is why I wanted to invest in FTDNA to explore my Y chromosome further. My kit is being shipped now, can't wait to send it back and get my results.
23ame just gave me R-L23, which isn't technically wrong, and told me I share a common ancestor with some legendary Irish king "of the three rivers" or something, rofl, what nonsense.
I mean, technically neither of these are wrong. You belong to R-L23 and you also share a paternal ancestor with that Irish king (actually with everyone who is R1b, lol).