Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15

Thread: According to the Harappaworld Calculator Iran Baloch and Pak Baloch aren't related?

  1. #1
    Registered Users
    Posts
    4

    According to the Harappaworld Calculator Iran Baloch and Pak Baloch aren't related?

    I am new to all this stuff, so I am trying to figure out what this all means. When I put in the coordinates for Iranian Baloch has a distance from Pakistani Baloch of 22 - Am I interpreting there results wrong or does it mean that Baloch is more of a shared cultural and linguistic group rather than a genetic cluster.

  2. #2
    Registered Users
    Posts
    392
    Sex
    Location
    Canada
    Ethnicity
    Parsi and Irani
    Nationality
    Pakistani and Indian

    Iran Sassanid Empire AchaemenidEmpire1 Pakistan India Iran Canada
    Quote Originally Posted by kesh View Post
    I am new to all this stuff, so I am trying to figure out what this all means. When I put in the coordinates for Iranian Baloch has a distance from Pakistani Baloch of 22 - Am I interpreting there results wrong or does it mean that Baloch is more of a shared cultural and linguistic group rather than a genetic cluster.
    Ye. I noticed that too and it's really confusing. Maybe the Pak Baloch sample is more mixed. Or maybe it includes Sindhis who identify as Balochi.

    Anyways, I think Pakistani Baloch are very very similar to Iranian Baluch.

  3. #3
    Registered Users
    Posts
    4

    Yeah that must be it, I can't think of any other logical reason - The distance should be about the same as a Bangladeshi and an Indian Bengali.

  4. #4
    Gold Class Member
    Posts
    2,263
    Sex
    Location
    NorCal
    Ethnicity
    Punjabi Jatt Sikh
    Nationality
    American & Canadian
    Y-DNA (P)
    L-M357 > Y91197
    mtDNA (M)
    HV2a3
    Y-DNA (M)
    L-M27
    mtDNA (P)
    R0

    United States of America California Republic Canada India Punjab Sikh Empire Nishan Sahib
    What do you mean by a distance of 22? Single population oracle distances?
    pegasus modeling:
    sample": "Punjabi_Jat:Sapporo_AGUser",
    "fit": 1.1506,
    "IRN_Shahr_I_Sokhta_BA3": 43.33,
    "TKM_Gonur1_BA": 31.67,
    "RUS_Sintashta_MLBA": 25,
    "closestDistances": [

    avatar credit goes out to aaronbee2010

  5. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Sapporo For This Useful Post:

     FrostAssassin0701 (05-17-2021),  Jatt1 (05-17-2021)

  6. #5
    Registered Users
    Posts
    392
    Sex
    Location
    Canada
    Ethnicity
    Parsi and Irani
    Nationality
    Pakistani and Indian

    Iran Sassanid Empire AchaemenidEmpire1 Pakistan India Iran Canada
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapporo View Post
    What do you mean by a distance of 22? Single population oracle distances?
    I don't know about OP, but that what I was wondering about. I think OP was asking about the same thing. The genetic distances (single population sharing) on the Vahaduo Harrapa World calculator between Iran Baloch and Pakistani Baloch are huge.

    No other calculator on Vahaduo has a separate Iranian Baluch category.

    Distance to Baloch Iran: Pakistani populations(except for Parsis) including Pakistani Baloch don't show up in the populations closest to Iranian Baloch.

     

    Distance to: Baloch_Iran
    4.13844174 Iranian_Bandari
    9.15329995 Parsi
    10.86543142 Tajik_Herat
    11.80872559 Pashtun_Kandahar
    12.25538657 Tajik_Shia&Qizilbash
    13.09240620 Iranian_Kerman
    13.73316060 Pashtun_North_Afghanistan
    13.79195780 Pashtun
    13.80772248 Iranian_Mashhad
    14.14007426 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    15.10696197 Tajik_Kabul
    16.11656911 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    16.19354501 Iranian_Shiraz
    16.74228479 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    16.98991171 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    17.62795791 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    18.22826377 Iraq_Domari
    18.25384069 Nuristani
    18.45096474 Dameli
    18.49641046 Turkmen
    18.54034250 Kho
    18.70663251 Iranian1
    18.76793276 Tajik_Kulo
    18.77233070 Mazandarani
    18.90187028 Tajik_Tajikistan

    Pakistani Baloch/Brahui/Makrani are closer to other Pakistanis and very far away from Iranian Baloch.

     
    Distance to: Baloch_Pakistan
    4.69084214 Brahui
    4.75340930 Makrani
    17.97091261 Bhatia
    18.31237833 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    18.66302762 Kalash
    18.99943683 Sindhi2
    19.23723733 Nuristani
    19.31870078 Pathan
    20.58965760 Sindhi1
    21.40428929 Punjabi_Malik
    21.50155343 Burusho
    21.91311251 Punjabi_Arain
    21.99330125 Dameli
    22.17498591 Baloch_Iran
    22.30663354 Sindhi_Memon
    22.43743969 Gawar
    22.49110269 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    22.84302082 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    22.84990372 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    23.09411180 Sindhi_Hindu
    23.15894428 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    23.43422924 Gujjar_Pakistan
    23.44765873 Pashtun
    23.47126967 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    23.52174101 Pashtun_Uthmankhel


    Look at how far away Makranis are from Iranian Baloch
     
    Distance to: Makrani
    4.75340930 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Brahui
    21.51153876 Baloch_Iran
    21.64421632 Kalash
    21.71122290 Bhatia
    21.80220631 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    22.00049545 Nuristani
    22.09925564 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.42910832 Pathan
    22.79940131 Sindhi2
    23.35566741 Iranian_Bandari
    23.83766557 Sindhi1
    24.29452202 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    24.58398462 Burusho
    24.59963008 Dameli
    25.06904266 Punjabi_Malik
    25.07185873 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    25.09844617 Pashtun
    25.73807297 Punjabi_Arain
    25.74249599 Pashtun_Kandahar
    25.82578169 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    25.83183307 Sindhi_Memon
    25.95197488 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    26.02503794 Gawar
    26.40187304 Sindhi_Hindu


    Brahuis
     
    Distance to: Brahui
    4.69084214 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Makrani
    21.58030352 Bhatia
    21.88254099 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.33902415 Sindhi2
    22.83177610 Kalash
    23.31323015 Nuristani
    23.49515269 Pathan
    24.71108253 Sindhi1
    25.07113081 Punjabi_Malik
    25.14039379 Burusho
    25.34173830 Punjabi_Arain
    25.56679683 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    26.14791196 Dameli
    26.18121846 Baloch_Iran
    26.25887469 Sindhi_Memon
    26.34448519 Gawar
    26.78021098 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    26.78122663 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    27.20328289 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    27.20564647 Sindhi_Hindu
    27.23472599 Gujjar_Pakistan
    27.39821710 Punjabi_Jatt_Sikh
    27.84771265 Pashtun
    27.85023878 Phalura
    Last edited by Azbuzz; 05-18-2021 at 01:55 AM.

  7. #6
    Gold Class Member
    Posts
    2,263
    Sex
    Location
    NorCal
    Ethnicity
    Punjabi Jatt Sikh
    Nationality
    American & Canadian
    Y-DNA (P)
    L-M357 > Y91197
    mtDNA (M)
    HV2a3
    Y-DNA (M)
    L-M27
    mtDNA (P)
    R0

    United States of America California Republic Canada India Punjab Sikh Empire Nishan Sahib
    Well, the first issue I see is the Baloch component on Harappa is based on the HGDP Baloch, Brahui and Makrani samples. It it maximized in them in contrast to Iranian Baloch (for non academic samples I've seen) who seems to score less of the Baloch component and more of the Caucasian components suggesting more Plateau Iranian ancestry from Western/Central Iranian populations (this likely translates to higher ANF and lower Iran N on G25 or higher Iran ChL ancestry and less BMAC). Anyways, do you have Iranian Baloch G25 coordinates? I'd like to compare them to the HGDP Pakistani Baloch and see how the raw distances manifest there as admixture calculators are outdated.
    Last edited by Sapporo; 05-18-2021 at 03:58 AM.
    pegasus modeling:
    sample": "Punjabi_Jat:Sapporo_AGUser",
    "fit": 1.1506,
    "IRN_Shahr_I_Sokhta_BA3": 43.33,
    "TKM_Gonur1_BA": 31.67,
    "RUS_Sintashta_MLBA": 25,
    "closestDistances": [

    avatar credit goes out to aaronbee2010

  8. The Following User Says Thank You to Sapporo For This Useful Post:

     laltota (05-18-2021)

  9. #7
    Moderator
    Posts
    1,303
    Sex
    Location
    CANZUK
    Ethnicity
    Bengali
    Nationality
    Canadian
    Y-DNA (P)
    J-Z2432
    mtDNA (M)
    A11-a*
    Y-DNA (M)
    H-Z12547*
    mtDNA (P)
    M30g

    Canada Bangladesh Jammu and Kashmir India Pakistan Sri Lanka
    Quote Originally Posted by Azbuzz View Post
    I don't know about OP, but that what I was wondering about. I think OP was asking about the same thing. The genetic distances (single population sharing) on the Vahaduo Harrapa World calculator between Iran Baloch and Pakistani Baloch are huge.

    No other calculator on Vahaduo has a separate Iranian Baluch category.

    Distance to Baloch Iran: Pakistani populations(except for Parsis) including Pakistani Baloch don't show up in the populations closest to Iranian Baloch.

     

    Distance to: Baloch_Iran
    4.13844174 Iranian_Bandari
    9.15329995 Parsi
    10.86543142 Tajik_Herat
    11.80872559 Pashtun_Kandahar
    12.25538657 Tajik_Shia&Qizilbash
    13.09240620 Iranian_Kerman
    13.73316060 Pashtun_North_Afghanistan
    13.79195780 Pashtun
    13.80772248 Iranian_Mashhad
    14.14007426 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    15.10696197 Tajik_Kabul
    16.11656911 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    16.19354501 Iranian_Shiraz
    16.74228479 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    16.98991171 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    17.62795791 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    18.22826377 Iraq_Domari
    18.25384069 Nuristani
    18.45096474 Dameli
    18.49641046 Turkmen
    18.54034250 Kho
    18.70663251 Iranian1
    18.76793276 Tajik_Kulo
    18.77233070 Mazandarani
    18.90187028 Tajik_Tajikistan

    Pakistani Baloch/Brahui/Makrani are closer to other Pakistanis and very far away from Iranian Baloch.

     
    Distance to: Baloch_Pakistan
    4.69084214 Brahui
    4.75340930 Makrani
    17.97091261 Bhatia
    18.31237833 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    18.66302762 Kalash
    18.99943683 Sindhi2
    19.23723733 Nuristani
    19.31870078 Pathan
    20.58965760 Sindhi1
    21.40428929 Punjabi_Malik
    21.50155343 Burusho
    21.91311251 Punjabi_Arain
    21.99330125 Dameli
    22.17498591 Baloch_Iran
    22.30663354 Sindhi_Memon
    22.43743969 Gawar
    22.49110269 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    22.84302082 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    22.84990372 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    23.09411180 Sindhi_Hindu
    23.15894428 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    23.43422924 Gujjar_Pakistan
    23.44765873 Pashtun
    23.47126967 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    23.52174101 Pashtun_Uthmankhel


    Look at how far away Makranis are from Iranian Baloch
     
    Distance to: Makrani
    4.75340930 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Brahui
    21.51153876 Baloch_Iran
    21.64421632 Kalash
    21.71122290 Bhatia
    21.80220631 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    22.00049545 Nuristani
    22.09925564 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.42910832 Pathan
    22.79940131 Sindhi2
    23.35566741 Iranian_Bandari
    23.83766557 Sindhi1
    24.29452202 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    24.58398462 Burusho
    24.59963008 Dameli
    25.06904266 Punjabi_Malik
    25.07185873 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    25.09844617 Pashtun
    25.73807297 Punjabi_Arain
    25.74249599 Pashtun_Kandahar
    25.82578169 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    25.83183307 Sindhi_Memon
    25.95197488 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    26.02503794 Gawar
    26.40187304 Sindhi_Hindu


    Brahuis
     
    Distance to: Brahui
    4.69084214 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Makrani
    21.58030352 Bhatia
    21.88254099 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.33902415 Sindhi2
    22.83177610 Kalash
    23.31323015 Nuristani
    23.49515269 Pathan
    24.71108253 Sindhi1
    25.07113081 Punjabi_Malik
    25.14039379 Burusho
    25.34173830 Punjabi_Arain
    25.56679683 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    26.14791196 Dameli
    26.18121846 Baloch_Iran
    26.25887469 Sindhi_Memon
    26.34448519 Gawar
    26.78021098 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    26.78122663 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    27.20328289 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    27.20564647 Sindhi_Hindu
    27.23472599 Gujjar_Pakistan
    27.39821710 Punjabi_Jatt_Sikh
    27.84771265 Pashtun
    27.85023878 Phalura
    "Vahaduo Harappa" is an unrealiable site, meaning there is no certainty of the data being used. Please refer to here.

  10. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Kulin For This Useful Post:

     Azbuzz (05-18-2021),  Kapisa (05-18-2021),  Sapporo (05-18-2021)

  11. #8
    Registered Users
    Posts
    392
    Sex
    Location
    Canada
    Ethnicity
    Parsi and Irani
    Nationality
    Pakistani and Indian

    Iran Sassanid Empire AchaemenidEmpire1 Pakistan India Iran Canada
    Quote Originally Posted by Sapporo View Post
    Well, the first issue I see is the Baloch component on Harappa is based on the HGDP Baloch, Brahui and Makrani samples. It it maximized in them in contrast to Iranian Baloch who seems to score less of the Baloch component and more of the Caucasian components suggesting more Pleteau Iranian ancestry from Western/Central Iranian populations (this likely translates to higher ANF and lower Iran N on G25 or higher Iran ChL ancestry and less BMAC. Anyways, do you have Iranian Baloch G25 coordinates? I'd like to compare them to the HGDP Pakistani Baloch and see how the raw distances manifest there as admixture calculators are outdated.
    Yes. Baloch in Iran have more Plateau Iranian. You're right about that. Baloch in Karachi/Sindh are more Sindhi admixed and Baloch in Oman are different a tad as well I think. I saw posts with the results on Anthrogenica a few months ago. I can't seem to find them anymore.

    I don't know about the Baloch in Afghanistan.

    I've seen old papers from the 2010s and they said Baloch in Iran cluster with Baloch in Pakistan.

  12. #9
    Registered Users
    Posts
    392
    Sex
    Location
    Canada
    Ethnicity
    Parsi and Irani
    Nationality
    Pakistani and Indian

    Iran Sassanid Empire AchaemenidEmpire1 Pakistan India Iran Canada
    Quote Originally Posted by Kulin View Post
    "Vahaduo Harappa" is an unrealiable site, meaning there is no certainty of the data being used. Please refer to here.
    Haha. LukaszM seems like a strange guy lol.

    Yes you are right about Harrapaworld Vahaduo being strange and unreliable sometimes. I was wondering why some of the population distances seemed so strange. Your post on LukaszM clarifies all my doubts.

  13. The Following User Says Thank You to Azbuzz For This Useful Post:

     Kulin (05-18-2021)

  14. #10
    Gold Class Member
    Posts
    4,394
    Location
    Shangri La

    Afghanistan Jammu and Kashmir United States of America Canada
    Quote Originally Posted by Azbuzz View Post
    I don't know about OP, but that what I was wondering about. I think OP was asking about the same thing. The genetic distances (single population sharing) on the Vahaduo Harrapa World calculator between Iran Baloch and Pakistani Baloch are huge.

    No other calculator on Vahaduo has a separate Iranian Baluch category.

    Distance to Baloch Iran: Pakistani populations(except for Parsis) including Pakistani Baloch don't show up in the populations closest to Iranian Baloch.

     

    Distance to: Baloch_Iran
    4.13844174 Iranian_Bandari
    9.15329995 Parsi
    10.86543142 Tajik_Herat
    11.80872559 Pashtun_Kandahar
    12.25538657 Tajik_Shia&Qizilbash
    13.09240620 Iranian_Kerman
    13.73316060 Pashtun_North_Afghanistan
    13.79195780 Pashtun
    13.80772248 Iranian_Mashhad
    14.14007426 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    15.10696197 Tajik_Kabul
    16.11656911 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    16.19354501 Iranian_Shiraz
    16.74228479 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    16.98991171 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    17.62795791 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    18.22826377 Iraq_Domari
    18.25384069 Nuristani
    18.45096474 Dameli
    18.49641046 Turkmen
    18.54034250 Kho
    18.70663251 Iranian1
    18.76793276 Tajik_Kulo
    18.77233070 Mazandarani
    18.90187028 Tajik_Tajikistan

    Pakistani Baloch/Brahui/Makrani are closer to other Pakistanis and very far away from Iranian Baloch.

     
    Distance to: Baloch_Pakistan
    4.69084214 Brahui
    4.75340930 Makrani
    17.97091261 Bhatia
    18.31237833 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    18.66302762 Kalash
    18.99943683 Sindhi2
    19.23723733 Nuristani
    19.31870078 Pathan
    20.58965760 Sindhi1
    21.40428929 Punjabi_Malik
    21.50155343 Burusho
    21.91311251 Punjabi_Arain
    21.99330125 Dameli
    22.17498591 Baloch_Iran
    22.30663354 Sindhi_Memon
    22.43743969 Gawar
    22.49110269 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    22.84302082 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    22.84990372 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    23.09411180 Sindhi_Hindu
    23.15894428 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    23.43422924 Gujjar_Pakistan
    23.44765873 Pashtun
    23.47126967 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    23.52174101 Pashtun_Uthmankhel


    Look at how far away Makranis are from Iranian Baloch
     
    Distance to: Makrani
    4.75340930 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Brahui
    21.51153876 Baloch_Iran
    21.64421632 Kalash
    21.71122290 Bhatia
    21.80220631 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    22.00049545 Nuristani
    22.09925564 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.42910832 Pathan
    22.79940131 Sindhi2
    23.35566741 Iranian_Bandari
    23.83766557 Sindhi1
    24.29452202 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    24.58398462 Burusho
    24.59963008 Dameli
    25.06904266 Punjabi_Malik
    25.07185873 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    25.09844617 Pashtun
    25.73807297 Punjabi_Arain
    25.74249599 Pashtun_Kandahar
    25.82578169 Pashtun_Uthmankhel
    25.83183307 Sindhi_Memon
    25.95197488 Pashtun_Yusufzai
    26.02503794 Gawar
    26.40187304 Sindhi_Hindu


    Brahuis
     
    Distance to: Brahui
    4.69084214 Baloch_Pakistan
    5.94623410 Makrani
    21.58030352 Bhatia
    21.88254099 Gujarati_Khoja_Sheikh
    22.33902415 Sindhi2
    22.83177610 Kalash
    23.31323015 Nuristani
    23.49515269 Pathan
    24.71108253 Sindhi1
    25.07113081 Punjabi_Malik
    25.14039379 Burusho
    25.34173830 Punjabi_Arain
    25.56679683 BMAC_Dzharkutan
    26.14791196 Dameli
    26.18121846 Baloch_Iran
    26.25887469 Sindhi_Memon
    26.34448519 Gawar
    26.78021098 Tajik_Panjshir&Kapisa
    26.78122663 Punjabi_Pahari_Gujjar
    27.20328289 Pashtun_Tarkalani
    27.20564647 Sindhi_Hindu
    27.23472599 Gujjar_Pakistan
    27.39821710 Punjabi_Jatt_Sikh
    27.84771265 Pashtun
    27.85023878 Phalura
    The core Baloch population from Eastern Iran are basically identical to the Pak Baloch with similar uniparental markers, if that sample has a distance that large, that "Baloch_Iran" is not a Baloch to begin with.

  15. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to pegasus For This Useful Post:

     Jatt1 (05-18-2021),  Kapisa (05-18-2021),  Sapporo (05-18-2021),  thejkhan (05-18-2021)

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. do sindhi / gujarati have mixed with baloch ?
    By sunni shafi'i in forum Southern
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 06-02-2020, 06:34 AM
  2. Replies: 18
    Last Post: 11-15-2019, 11:22 PM
  3. Baloch/Gulf Arab confusion
    By hartaisarlag in forum Western
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 10-30-2019, 05:42 AM
  4. About sindhi and baloch jats
    By gudar in forum Southern
    Replies: 22
    Last Post: 06-29-2019, 05:27 PM
  5. Living DNA Baloch Component
    By Gandhara in forum Southern
    Replies: 17
    Last Post: 06-22-2017, 02:09 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •