Guys, I have no time or patience right now to address the semantic circles you're all running in. In fact, I believe I've already addressed this to some extent, but obviously that hasn't made an impact on the discussion.
But I will say that you should tone it down and cut out the accusations and ad hominems, or this thread will be permanently closed.
Gentica277282 (10-24-2022)
I do not accuse. You do and are. You are conflating 19th century geopolitical terms to identify the cultural history of the middle east and using it to genetically identify components you view favorable fit your world view of ashkenazim. No one ever does this. No one, except for you and a few others I won't mention.Originally Posted by Gentica277282
Leave him, you said. and you should leave, because you are offensive and biased.
Appreciate it.
Better to permanently close a thread that allows others to geoculturally attack other's histories by intropersonal bias, than to allow it to continue and escalate.There are plenty of other platforms they can take that, such as europedia.
It's really ubsurd he's been playing the strawman game for this long. This impeded honest discourse.
Well then, this thread is now closed. It's obviously not productive, and there are plenty of other threads with less problematic guiding questions where Ashkenazi ethnogenesis can be and has been discussed more productively. I hope a more open and less hostile spirit of discussion can prevail there.
Freb (10-24-2022), Gentica277282 (10-24-2022), Levantine_Viking (10-24-2022), Targum (10-26-2022)
Posting Permissions
