Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18

Thread: L193 geographics

  1. #1
    Registered Users
    Posts
    305
    Sex
    Omitted

    L193 geographics

    Hi All,

    I just wanted to start a mini-thread on observations of L193. Some info has come up which might be of interest.

    Like many L193 folks, I trace back to Ayrshire/Dumfriesshire, 18th century. But I see more and more popping up further west, in Argyll, and across into central Scotland, and as far up as the Outer Hebrides and Inverness (with surnames which match those areas).

    My closest FTDNA matches are Elliott (#2), Meek (#2), Templeton, Glendinning and most recently, Duncan.

    Templeton can be regarded as a 'new' surname, coming from a place-name in Ayrshire. Glendinning the same, near Dumfries (but as I understand there is a link appearing with a Glendinning and the Elliotts through the new testing: so they may be one and the same stock).

    Here's where it gets interesting: Elliott, a big border clan, has an origin story/myth that they originally came from the village/river Elliot, in Angus in central-east Scotland. And indeed there is some evidence to support the story, that King Robert brought them into the borders area to help police the region. This was not without precedent: the Gordons moved up north from the borders, for instance.
    Meek is not necessarily a borders name at all: it appears in Ayrshire/Galloway, but I suspect as a corruption of the older name McMeekin/McMeeking: check out these names on GB surnames profiler and you'll see what I mean:http://gbnames.publicprofiler.org/default.aspx
    When in its regular form, Meek is much more common again in east central Scotland: Angus and Fife.
    Duncan, my most recent match, is one of the oldest surnames in Scotland, and is almost exclusively originated from central/east Scotland, where it is claimed it goes back to King Duncan of Dunkeld. The Clan Duncan is certainly from that area, and is part of the larger Clan Donnachie (Robertson).

    It struck me that my old grandfather once very quietly said that he remembered one of his old relatives talking about a male-line connection to Coupar Angus...we all dismissed it as unlikely, and maybe he was getting his facts mixed up. After all, the paper trail for me ends in Ayrshire. BUT we lose the thread before 1740-something, and the highest concentration of my surname is, surprise: in central Scotland - Perth, Clackmannan, Angus etc. Before the 1740's, there are no families by the name in Ayrshire. They are incomers. And that period was one of major migration for religious and political reasons in Scotland.

    The 'explosion' of L193 is clearly south/west. But could the cradle actually be up there in the ancient royal centre, around Perth/Angus? So many of my genealogical strands would tie up with this scenario, but I am just not sure if the DNA trail is solid enough to support this either way...

    Jon

  2. The Following User Says Thank You to Jon For This Useful Post:

     Dave-V (09-25-2014)

  3. #2
    Registered Users
    Posts
    343
    Sex
    Location
    USA
    Nationality
    USA
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b-L21 L513*

    United States of America Ireland Germany Belgium Wallonia
    Jon, we've talked about the Vance piece of L193 before and I've posted elsewhere so apologies if this is repetitive.

    But to add a piece to your puzzle, the L193-A1V Vances seem closest to the A1Ms but the closest surnames are Glendenning, Elliott, McClain and Little. From a paper trail standpoint there are two observations:

    1. The A1V subgroup includes a line reliably documented back to 1451 in Galloway (Wigtown area), although the surname already appears in earlier records in the area and is said to have started there in 1384.
    2. Other kits in the subgroup have documented ancestries in Ireland back to at least the early 1700s, with at least 3 known men of the Scottish family who had ties or emigrated to that part of Ireland in the early 1600s. The strong implication therefore is that we can rule out NPEs in the Scottish line at least back to the early 1700s but more likely to the early 1600s.

    Now the Galloway family (Vans) had at least two known separate Scottish branches, one in Inverness and the other in Aberdeenshire not far from Angus. The Aberdeen Vans line was mentioned in wills of the Galloway family so their connection is known, and there is even a suggestion in the records that one of the emigrants to Ireland was of the Aberdeen line which if true would go a long way towards placing A1V around Aberdeen as well at least back then.

    There are strong heraldic, marriage ties with other families and historic reference connections for the origin of these families back to the Vaux/Vaus of Dirleton in East Lothian in eastern Scotland but a gap of one or two generations in the line of descent. But the Vaux/Vaus had Norman origins, so either the origins of L193 are more complicated, or the Vans origin story is way off after that point, or L193 came into the surname line through an NPE etc.

    However, to your point on the direction of movement, the Vaux/Vaus/Vans surname came into Scotland in the late 1200s into East Lothian and migrated southwest to Galloway by possibly 1384 or at least 1451. It's possible L193 joined at some point after the 1200s, but we know it was in the surname line by the 1600/1700s. But the other branches of the surname that spread around Scotland complicates the picture a bit.

    Dave

  4. The Following User Says Thank You to Dave-V For This Useful Post:

     Jon (09-25-2014)

  5. #3
    Registered Users
    Posts
    305
    Sex
    Omitted

    Thanks Dave.

    I'm starting to get very wary of surname histories now as I'm discovering that almost every one has several possible backgrounds: my own name of Sharp is in the first place old English (from Scearpa); in Scotland can also be a translation of a Gaelic name in the west (MacIlheran), and has even been claimed as a French-derived name (from L'Escharpe). And the more I look into L193 names, the same thing happens: no real uniformity. There are English, Gaelic and French-derived names...on top of that, I read that only 50% of us statistically have our 'real' names, thanks to adoption, maternal surname inheritance, NPE etc, over the centuries since we inherited the name in the first place! I'm a good case in point: so far I do not match a single other Sharp in the FTDNA project, even those from Ayrshire!

    So I'm trying to look more now at the pattern of where L193 comes up. It seems to me very Scottish: I mean the few Irish and English folks also seem to have links through surnames to Scotland. According to the FTDNA map, it seems quite well spread across the whole country though...and recent too.

    I still wonder who Mr L193 could have been...!

  6. The Following User Says Thank You to Jon For This Useful Post:

     Dave-V (09-25-2014)

  7. #4
    Registered Users
    Posts
    343
    Sex
    Location
    USA
    Nationality
    USA
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b-L21 L513*

    United States of America Ireland Germany Belgium Wallonia
    Agreed, Jon. In old L513 Yahoo Group posts (where we used to call the Mr. L193 "Mr. Big") he looked most likely to be a southwestern Scottish person of some note given the spread of his lineage around Scotland. I'm not sure that stands up fully at this point, but it seems pretty clear that L193 had a unique explosion in Scotland somewhere in medieval times.

    Of course the L193 progenitor is estimated to have lived anywhere from 450AD to 900AD depending on error factors and who's running the numbers, so at least 300-750 years before most of the surname histories started that carry L193, not to mention the span of time that people still regularly changed surnames. Given its age there was plenty of time, IMHO, before surnames for L193 to have originated outside Scotland and we're just seeing one or more descendant lines who moved to Scotland and proliferated, or even for one or more branches of L193 to have left Scotland and come back.

    I'm hoping the SNP tsunami from recent NGS tests gives us a better tree structure for the L193 surname lines that we can start to make better sense of it.

    Dave

  8. The Following User Says Thank You to Dave-V For This Useful Post:

     Jon (09-26-2014)

  9. #5
    Registered Users
    Posts
    305
    Sex
    Omitted

    Interesting Dave. I guess I can get too Scotland-focused on L193. I mean given the western bias, there is the chance of Irish incursion - especially in the timeframe 450-900AD. But that would also include Vikings and Anglians! Plus as far as I know there is no real close brother clade in Ireland; the old A2 bunch I guess, but A7 and the other new groups have shown that to not be so close. If L193 was Dalriada, for instance, you would expect to see a lot more of it there today. A pet theory of mine was the Gall-gaidheal, or foreign Gaels, who gave Galloway its name and came into that region around 800AD. They came from the Hebrides and Argyll, and would also have had relatives in central Scotland...but anything is fair game I suppose. Maybe we'll never know for sure. What I really hope is that if there was for instance an NPE in my line, that I can maybe one day find out which surname/s to look for as I continue my searching. That would be really cool!

  10. The Following User Says Thank You to Jon For This Useful Post:

     Dave-V (09-26-2014)

  11. #6
    Registered Users
    Posts
    1,778
    Sex
    Location
    Dún Laoire, Bláth Cliath, Éire
    Ethnicity
    Gael
    Nationality
    Éireanach
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b-DF41
    mtDNA (M)
    U4d3

    Ireland
    Well if you are talking about South-West Scotland wouldn't the Brythonic kingdom of Strathclyde/Cumbria not be a possible source for L193. After all Galloway in sense was carved out of this only in 9th-10th centuries.

    What's interesting is that A2 is splilt between A7 (along with L193 has scottish surnames in the L193- section) and large "Airgíalla II" cluster in Ireland. What's interesting about this is there is clear signs in archaelogy of connections between Northern Britain and the northern half of Ireland after 200bc. Clogher hillfort (right in middle of what became Airgíalla territory) for example is often seen as a "island" of brythonic influence in the area (going on finds etc.).

    My feeling is that A2 probably arose in Britain with A7 staying in northern Britain (where it begat L193) and the cluster of SNP's that mark Airgíalla II arriving into Ireland. There it languished for bit undergoing a bottleneck until the Maguire's took over lordship of Fermanagh in the 13th century.

    -Paul
    (R1b-DF41+)
    (MtDNA: U4d3)

    How to pronounce my username (modern Irish):
    Hidden Content

  12. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Dubhthach For This Useful Post:

     Jon (09-27-2014),  Mag Uidhir 6 (11-08-2014),  TigerMW (09-29-2014)

  13. #7
    Registered Users
    Posts
    305
    Sex
    Omitted

    Hi Paul,

    Yes, Strathclyde has occurred to me. But would that not mean closer links in north England, and especially Wales where the Britons of Strathclyde were said to have retreated to? Also, the high number of guys with ancestry in Argyll, and up into the central highlands made me wonder as well. I mean after so much time the Strathclyde descendants would of course have spread...but L193 still seems stubbornly Scottish, with very little close connection outside. I have recently been wondering about Picts, actually: maybe these are the mysterious 'southern Picts' mentioned in the annals?!

    I totally agree that it looks like an insular Celtic connection, though, with the different groups of L513 spread all over.

  14. #8
    Registered Users
    Posts
    4,414
    Sex
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b
    mtDNA (M)
    H

    We do have some new information on this. When looking for origins it is good to look for locations of diversity, or in the case of SNPs, early branching. It's like asking where do the cousins live? L193 is really just the "lead with" or first found SNP of a phylogenetic block that marks this branch of L193. Until now that block was probably

    L193/S176/L193.1
    S5979
    Z17623
    A4
    A5
    A6
    S7123
    S5990
    Z16332
    S5982
    Z16333
    S5992

    The challenge is that you don't know which SNPs are oldest or youngest in a block. We just found out about split in the L193 block.

    f216154 Jolley

    ... has S5979 Z17623 but appears ancestral for the rest.

    This would make Jolley the nearest "cousin" to L193. He has one person I can find that fits with him in a STR signature:

    f93174 Bussey

    I'm pretty sure he is also S5979 Z17623.

    I can't find any origins information beyond the US for these two. The only things that I know of to look at our the surnames themselves.

    What I read in the general searches is that these are Old English names and possibly of the Old French variety, particularly for Bussey.

  15. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to TigerMW For This Useful Post:

     Dubhthach (11-08-2014),  Mag Uidhir 6 (11-08-2014)

  16. #9
    Registered Users
    Posts
    49
    Sex
    Location
    Olympic Coast
    Ethnicity
    100% Mutt mostly Irish
    Nationality
    American
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b-L513/Z16337

    United States of America Ireland Scotland Germany Imperial
    Jon,

    The linkage between L193 and L69.5 is indeed and actual point in history. Nailing it down by year....I'd say is a work in progress. And while I question most Pedigrees, they often DO provide clues to branching points. The split of S5668 at A7 & FGC9807, I believe, occurs around 200BC. This a SWAG while looking at Jim and Arlan's pedigree chart at http://homepages.rootsweb.ancestry.c...e/Pedigree.htm scroll down to [66]Aonghus Tuireach Tamach (226-B.C.) for a possible branch point.

    By no means is this THE DEFINITIVE Maguire line of descent. But, when we look at the new NGS branching of SNPs in relation to FGC9807 Surnames, this chart is gaining in validity (in my opinion).

    Prior to 900AD, I have a hard time assigning TRUE names to various clans or progenitors, simply because I don't have the breadth of research in either genealogy, languages or historical references, merely a dabbling in familiarity with a few. And there's the whole Clan Colla origination legend that I find somewhat "awkward" to fully grasp.

    Having said all that: The first note in the Annals shows Uidhir at 956AD, which is "close enough" for me to realize that whole surname generation thing. Here is direct copy and paste of "that guy" - --Point to the Maguire Progenitor[19]Maic hUidir<--
    The Progenitor of the Maguire Family (approximately 920-A.D.)
    The first mention, known to date, of Maguire in ancient documents
    comes from the 'Annals of the Four Masters' quote translated by
    John O'Donovan, Dublin, 1851.

    A.D. 956:
    ".... Tanaidhe Mac Midhir, Successor of
    Comhgall, was killed by the foreigners."

    Kathleen Neil of the "Maguire Clan Society" has researched the
    origin of Maguire and it points thus far to Westmeath.

    Okay....that seems to match up with a logical FGC9807 guy, in my opinion. We have to scroll down a bit more to fully grasp the septs that emerged from the main Mag Uidhir line. Another cut and paste is in order due to the complexity:

    | |
    (1200 A.D.) First English [27]Don - The Elder (Established the Murchadh
    counties appear in Ireland. family around the late 1200's.) (a progenitor of yet
    another Murphy family)
    A.D. 1302:
    "Donn Maguire, King of
    Fermanagh, namely the
    first king of Fermanagh
    of the sons of Maguire,
    rested in Christ."

    This quote is the first mention of
    Maguire in 'The Annals of Ulster.'
    It is believed that O'Donnell of
    Tir Chonaill was the Maguire's
    first overlord and helped establish
    them. Later on, after Tomas Mor the
    6th Prince, O'Neill of Tyrone would
    take tribute also claiming lordship
    over Maguire & Fermanagh. The
    Maguire's were the middle child
    often times making peace between
    O'Donnell & O'Neill. The lordship
    shifted back & forth between the two
    & many times both acted as overlord
    at twice the price) For the sons of
    Don Mor See #806 of the
    Fermanagh Genealogies
    |
    __________________________________________________ ________________________________________
    | | | |
    [28]Gilla Isa Gothraidh Gaillghile Maghnus
    which means 'servant of Jesus' (a progenitor of the (progenitor of the (a progenitor of the
    (Besides continuing the Maguire Corry family Lilly family MacManus family)
    line Giolla also was the progenitor "GF" #858) "GF" #143 |
    of the Gilleece Family) Ruaidhri (Rory)
    | |
    [29]Domnaill __________________________
    | | |
    _________________________ Maghnus Maolsheaclainn
    | | | |
    [1]Duind Carrach Lochlain Matthew Brian
    1st Prince 1264-1303 (a progenitor of the | (progenitor of the
    (26th in descent from McLoughlin family) Giolla Phadraig Breen family)
    de Colla da Chrioch |
    according to the Cathal
    "Geinealaighe Fearmanach" |
    p.71 "The Line of Cathal or Charles MacManus
    Philip Mac Guidhir") Maguire - The Middle (1439-1498)
    | Author of 'The Annals of Ulster'
    | Most likely a contemporary
    | of Tomas Og the 7th Prince
    |
    |
    __________________________________________________ __________________________
    | | | |
    [2]Flaithbertaig MacCraith Gafraidh Amloamh
    2nd Prince (progenitor of the (a progenitor of the (a progenitor of the
    1303-1324 MacGrath family of McCaffery family MacAuley family
    | Sillees "GF" #143) "GF" #876) "GF" #806)
    | |
    Gailic Laws of Inheritance & the (deirfine) __________________________________________
    In old Irish law the taoiseach or leadership of a tuath or kingdom was | |
    not only handed down from father to eldest son but all male line Philib Mathghamhain or Mahon
    descendants in a family of a common great-grand-father were | (a progenitor of the
    considered brothers of inheritance, this would include second cousins. ______________________ MacMahon family)
    This basic four generation group was called a deirfine or land ruling | |
    family which defined the way in which property would be handled after Brian Aodh
    the death of the head of a family. The property was held in common & (progenitor of the
    when the son's formed new deirfines, (as above), the land was re-distributed McHugh family)
    accordingly for private ownership within the new deirfines. This
    periodic re-distribution was named the gabhail cine or the gavelkind.
    At times, because so many were eligible for the chieftancy within a
    family, there would be squables & murder would occur.
    In an attempt to stop the squables an election of sorts was developed to
    choose a king elect called a tanaiste (tanist), this was done during the
    life of the present princes reign by freemen of the tuath or
    kingdom and only for a member of the deirfine or land ruling
    family. In time many seemingly unimportant qualifications developed
    to weed out competitors for example the law of "being without blemish."
    In an attempt to maintain peace & order many noble Irish families
    turned to a system of alternating succession between two or more branches.
    So although there is a change in the branch (below) the lines of Rory and
    Hugh seemed to have maintained peace and order through it.
    This will again be seen with the spliting between the Senior Lisnaskea
    branch & the Junior Tempo or Enniskillen branch.
    |
    |---------------------------------------------------+
    | |
    [3]Rory an Einigh 3rd Prince (the Generous) 1324-1332 [4]Aeda(Hugh) (Ruadh) (I) 4th Prince 1332-1360
    + |
    |
    |
    +-------------<Main Line of Descent)----------------+
    |
    |
    |---------------------------------------------------+
    | |
    [5]Philip na Tuaighe 5th Prince (Battleaxe) 1360-1375 Gormlaith
    |
    |------------------------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-----------------+----------------+---------------------+----------------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+------------+---------+----------+----------+
    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
    [6]Thomas Mor 6th Prince (The Black Gillie) 1375-1430 Hugh(Aodh) Nenagh 1438 Donn (1) Maelseachlain Cuchonnaght(1) Art of Coole Manus (fostered in Tyrone) Donn(2) Brian Cuchonnaght(2) Donn Rua Sean Turlough Tadhg Domhnall Rua
    | | |
    | | +--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
    | | |
    | +--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Rory
    | | |
    +------------(Main Line of Descent>-----------+ | +-----------+---------------+
    | = <6 Unknown Generations) | | |
    | | Arthur Alexander Francis d. 1811
    +--------------------------------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------------+ Richard Maguire |
    | | Known to be 7th in descent from Hugh +-----------+------------+
    Senior Branch of the town of Lisnaskea Junior Branch of the town of Tempo | | | |
    | | +----------------+-----------------+ Capt. Alexander Dr. John Thomas
    [7]Tomas Og Maguire 7th Prince 1430-1480 Pilib Mac Thomais Mhoir

    This doesn't do justice to Jim and Arlan's website due to formatting so, please, go to the main site to properly view the septs and branch points. My summation of them is:

    Uidhir 956AD FGC9807 (Probably where Clarke, Corrigan, Garvey, branch)

    Donn Mor Mag Uidhir 1200AD FGC9800 (Main Maguire/Plunkett/McCown lines)
    ZS347 (Burns, Byrne)
    Z20655 (Bruen, McCormick, possibly Lilly, Corry, McManus, Breen)

    Donn Carrach Maguire 1302AD FGC9800 (Main Maguire/Plunkett/McCown lines)
    P66 (McCown split - probable DCM son/grandson-we estimate this as mid 1400s)
    Z16337 - Main Maguire line with follow on branching by Plunkett, McLoughlin, MacAuley, McGrath, McCaffery,
    unk SNP - MacAuley may show MacMahon and McHugh

    Still scratching my head for most of this, but this is the template that I use to try to piece this mystery together.

    Brad

  17. #10
    Registered Users
    Posts
    1,778
    Sex
    Location
    Dún Laoire, Bláth Cliath, Éire
    Ethnicity
    Gael
    Nationality
    Éireanach
    Y-DNA (P)
    R1b-DF41
    mtDNA (M)
    U4d3

    Ireland
    Brad,

    you might appreciate the following, it's some photo's I've taken from TM Charles-Edwards "Early Christian Ireland" specifically covering the relationship between the Aírgialla and the Uí Néill, what's evident is the connection between the two is a classic example of forged genealogy for political reasons. In general the whole "Three Colla's" appears an artificial construct:

    http://compsoc.nuigalway.ie/~dubhtha...airgialla.html

    -Paul
    (R1b-DF41+)
    (MtDNA: U4d3)

    How to pronounce my username (modern Irish):
    Hidden Content

  18. The Following User Says Thank You to Dubhthach For This Useful Post:

     Mag Uidhir 6 (11-09-2014)

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Study of L193 surnames
    By Nqp15hhu in forum L513
    Replies: 17
    Last Post: 06-07-2020, 10:09 PM
  2. New surname leads for L193?
    By Jon in forum L513
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 05-03-2019, 09:04 AM
  3. Surname/DNA analysis for L193
    By Jon in forum L513
    Replies: 37
    Last Post: 04-01-2019, 02:50 PM
  4. Sykes and L193
    By Jon in forum L513
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 06-20-2015, 11:59 AM
  5. Maclean history/L193
    By Jon in forum L513
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 05-04-2015, 11:55 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •